Lexicon Foundation

Encounter

Definition

Encounter is what happens between two people when neither reduces the other to an object — a philosophical reality that takes place in the space between and transforms both.

Two hands meeting across a bridge of light

Encounter happens when two people sit facing each other — one speaks, the other listens. So far, nothing remarkable. Then something shifts: the listener no longer hears only the words but the person speaking them. They perceive what lies behind the words, beneath what is said, in the space between the two of them. In that moment, encounter is no longer a word for a social situation but a philosophical reality.

#I-Thou and I-It

Martin Buber (1878–1965), in I and Thou (1923), articulated the distinction that lays bare the core of this reality (Buber, 1923, I and Thou). A person can meet their counterpart in two fundamental attitudes: as It or as Thou. In the I-It attitude, the other is an object — something observed, used, categorised. This attitude is unavoidable and not reprehensible. But where it becomes the only one, life withers, even when it functions outwardly. “All real living is meeting,” Buber wrote (Buber, 1923), and went on: no purpose, no greed and no anticipation stand between I and Thou; only “where all means have fallen away” does the meeting take place (ibid.).

Buber went further: “In the beginning is relation” (Buber, 1923). Not the individual first and relation second, but relation first and then the individual. The human being becomes an I through the Thou.

#Feelings as Spatial Realities

In the phenomenology of the lived body developed by Hermann Schmitz, feelings are, as Jochen Kirchhoff sums it up, real entities in space, beyond the subject (G. Kirchhoff / J. Kirchhoff, 2024, Außenwelt Innenwelt, 54:23–54:41). In the same conversation Jochen Kirchhoff says that anger in antiquity, also as thymos, was a real force that seizes a person; Gwendolin Kirchhoff adds Achilles, whom wrath seizes (ibid., 54:52–55:19); the Iliad names the wrath of Achilles in its first word mēnis (Homer, Iliad I, 1). The modern person, Jochen Kirchhoff says, thinks such feelings could not seize him; yet whole societies are seized by them (G. Kirchhoff / J. Kirchhoff, 2024, Außenwelt Innenwelt, 55:29–55:44).

Following Buber, Gwendolin Kirchhoff puts it this way: every feeling is, at its core, a relation between two in space and describes “the bond between these two”; the fullness of human emotionality springs from I-Thou, not from I-It (G. Kirchhoff, 2024, Systemisches Familienstellen (nach Bert Hellinger), eine Einführung, 02:17–02:36). Whoever engages with the theme of family, she says, engages with the essential core of the human being as a relational being (ibid., 03:11–03:19).

#Compassion in Schopenhauer

Arthur Schopenhauer (1788–1860) approached the core of encounter from a different direction. He described how, for the one who practises works of love, “the veil of Maya has become transparent”: “he recognises himself, his self, his will in every being, and consequently also in the one who suffers” (Schopenhauer, 1819, The World as Will and Representation, vol. I, § 66). The principium individuationis, the illusion of separateness, is just that — an illusion. Compassion sees through this illusion; Schopenhauer sums up the insight in the formula of the Veda: “Tat twam asi!” (“This thou art!”) (ibid., § 66).

“I set out my little offering bowls around me, so that others can find nourishment in them”

— Gwendolin Kirchhoff, Victoria Film: Tiefgang — Eine Gesellschaft muss auf die Couch, 2022

Schopenhauer’s insight touches a question that also concerns encounter: whether I can, through my own interiority, also reach the interiority of the other — whether I can feel my way into it. Gwendolin Kirchhoff raises this question in a conversation with Jochen Kirchhoff about Schopenhauer and remarks that in Kant it would have been denied: there is, she says, a fixed gap that never goes away; one cannot get through to the other (G. Kirchhoff / J. Kirchhoff, 2021, Was wollte Schopenhauer?, 27:18–27:56).

#Yes, Please, Thank You

In constellation work (Familienaufstellung), the structure of encounter becomes visible in concrete practice. Gwendolin Kirchhoff names three words for openness in a couple relationship, actually three magic words, as she says: Yes, Please, Thank You (G. Kirchhoff, 2024, Systemisches Familienstellen (nach Bert Hellinger), eine Einführung, 33:52–35:39). The Yes means: I look at the other with everything that belongs to them — their whole family, all their entanglements, their entire fate — and say Yes with full awareness. The second is Please: I make no demands but acknowledge that I am asking someone to open themselves to me. And the third is Thank You: perceiving what the other gives and letting it into my heart.

Relationship problems, she says, rest on something catching in these three words (ibid., 34:00–34:09). At the same time, as Gwendolin Kirchhoff puts it, between equals, for instance in a couple relationship, giving and receiving want to be in balance (G. Kirchhoff, 2024, Systemisches Familienstellen (nach Bert Hellinger), 24:57–25:06). Where one person consistently gives more, they place themselves in the parental role, as her example from a couple relationship shows (ibid., 25:16–25:58).

#How do you talk to people you disagree with?

Talking to people you disagree with, rather than refusing the conversation: in a conversation with Maik Hosang (2025), Gwendolin Kirchhoff says that the idea “that one shouldn’t even talk” “doesn’t necessarily have the effect that is hoped for”; consideration for the people one is in contact with “only comes about through being in contact with them.” Just before, she says: “Whereas we assume that through communication and out of the opposites” a process of change takes place in both. She adds: “Which doesn’t mean that one has to convert to everything someone else says,” and: “that is no compulsion to consensus every time.”

Earlier in the same conversation she asks what it takes so that one “doesn’t have to fall into camp thinking so much,” and answers with the idea “that everything has a fertile ground”: even if, say, a party doesn’t appeal to you, there are concerns underneath, and “the concern has to be addressed, otherwise nothing happens there.” Then, she says, one has a different, more peaceful, more relaxed view, a view “that is less ideologically cramped.” That does not mean approving of everything, but rather that “more crumple zone comes about.”

Maik Hosang takes up this thought (“as you just said”): someone facing a person who is perhaps criticising them at that moment can at first suffer from it and feel attacked, or, as the “higher art,” recognise: “there is something behind it, too. There is a person with an experience behind it.” Whoever looks at it from a meta-perspective, he says, can ask why the other is different, and what, in what only seems foreign, could enrich one.

In the same conversation Gwendolin Kirchhoff tells of an exchange with someone with whom she disagrees on one question. The conversation, she says, moved into quite different subjects, and she “came out of the conversation with a warm feeling of connectedness.” She still assumed that she was actually right in her view, she says, but she could listen well to his. It is, she believes, very important, precisely with people who are very different, “simply to get in contact through questions.” One is often out and about in one’s own bubbles, she says; it is “quite nice to leave the bubble for once” and, out of curiosity about the other, to look at what the other is like “when he thinks quite differently.” When the conversation turns to the ability to recognise one’s own conditioning, she adds the thought “that the idea could even arise at all”: “I could be blinkered.”

The conversation is one of a series with Maik Hosang on metamodernism; what Hosang means by it and what Gwendolin Kirchhoff puts to him is described in the entry Metamodernism.

Related entries: Buber: I and Thou, Thinking Empathy, Second-Order Perception.

#Space as Medium

Space has, as Gwendolin Kirchhoff says in a conversation with Jochen Kirchhoff, the quality of creating proximity; it is a contact surface, the medium through which things come into contact (G. Kirchhoff / J. Kirchhoff, 2024, Die Anderswelt: Nachdenken über den Tod (2), 22:32–22:47). In another conversation with Jochen Kirchhoff she describes how the spatial standing-towards-each-other of two people, which shows itself in feeling, can be re-enacted in a family constellation: the people one has feelings for are placed in the room (G. Kirchhoff / J. Kirchhoff, 2024, Außenwelt Innenwelt, 53:41–54:22). Whoever enters into philosophical work enters this space, and what occurs there between two people cannot be planned — but it is prepared by the willingness to truly perceive the other as Thou.

“I always put it quite simply: meaning is insight, happiness is contact”

— Gwendolin Kirchhoff, Werden wir gelebt? – HOPE documentary interview (Kai Stuth), 2024

Encounter is grounded in Thinking Empathy: a thinking that feels and a feeling that thinks. Without this stance, the other remains It, even in the most well-intentioned conversation. In Philosophical Accompaniment, encounter is the sustaining quality of the dialogue. In Recognition, encounter finds its ethical expression: the Yes to the other that precedes being seen. Anyone looking for this quality of encounter will find in philosophical consultation the setting in which it can unfold.

#Sources

  • Buber, M. (1923). Ich und Du. Leipzig: Insel. English edition: I and Thou, trans. Ronald Gregor Smith, Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark, 1937.
  • Homer. Iliad I, 1.
  • Kirchhoff, G. (2022). Tiefgang — Eine Gesellschaft muss auf die Couch [Video, German]. Victoria Film, YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xw_NCbZSDAo (01:18:48–01:20:43).
  • Kirchhoff, G. (2024). Systemisches Familienstellen (nach Bert Hellinger), eine Einführung [Video, German]. SYMPOSIUM, YouTube, Gwendolin Kirchhoff’s channel. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kwd1x1RzNoE (02:17–03:19, 24:57–25:58, 33:52–35:39).
  • Kirchhoff, G. (2024). Werden wir gelebt? – HOPE-Doku-Interview [Video, German]. HOPE Doku, Odysee (apolut). Not on YouTube (01:04:15–01:05:41).
  • Kirchhoff, G. / Hosang, M. (2025). Meta-Bewusstsein: Wie wir über das Ich hinauswachsen – Ein Gespräch mit Prof. Maik Hosang [Video, German]. YouTube, Gwendolin Kirchhoff’s channel. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=389k2vN9idY (Gwendolin Kirchhoff 21:01–21:46, 23:28–24:04, 24:24–25:33, 25:54–26:03 and 27:03–27:09; Maik Hosang 21:49–22:54).
  • Kirchhoff, G. / Kirchhoff, J. (2021). Was wollte Schopenhauer? [Video, German]. YouTube, Jochen Kirchhoff – In Memoriam. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bf8BeB3mbwc (Gwendolin Kirchhoff 27:18–27:56).
  • Kirchhoff, G. / Kirchhoff, J. (2024). Außenwelt Innenwelt – Das Doppelwesen Mensch [Video, German]. YouTube, Jochen Kirchhoff – In Memoriam. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AwUypSVSIyI (Gwendolin Kirchhoff 53:41–54:22 and 55:11–55:15; Jochen Kirchhoff 54:23–54:41, 54:52–55:10 and 55:29–55:44; times from the audio track, not the transcript).
  • Kirchhoff, G. / Kirchhoff, J. (2024). Die Anderswelt: Nachdenken über den Tod (2) – Ein Gespräch mit Jochen Kirchhoff [Video, German]. SYMPOSIUM, YouTube, Gwendolin Kirchhoff’s channel. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o-secv4Z-pM (Gwendolin Kirchhoff 22:32–22:47).
  • Schopenhauer, A. (1819). Die Welt als Wille und Vorstellung. Leipzig: Brockhaus. English edition: The World as Will and Representation, trans. E. F. J. Payne, New York: Dover, 1958.

Frequently Asked Questions

What distinguishes a genuine encounter from an ordinary conversation?
In a philosophical encounter, the listener no longer hears only the words but the person speaking them. Something arises in the space between, where neither reduces the other to an object. Buber called this the I-Thou attitude, as distinct from the I-It attitude that observes and categorises the other.
What does it mean to understand feelings as spatial entities?
In the phenomenology of the lived body developed by Hermann Schmitz, feelings are, as Jochen Kirchhoff sums it up, real entities in space, beyond the subject. In a conversation with Gwendolin Kirchhoff, Jochen Kirchhoff says that anger in antiquity, also as thymos, was a real force that seizes a person; she adds Achilles, whom wrath seizes. The Iliad names the wrath of Achilles in its first word mēnis. Gwendolin Kirchhoff calls every feeling, at its core, a relation between two in space.
What role does space play in philosophical encounter?
In a conversation with Jochen Kirchhoff, Gwendolin Kirchhoff calls space a contact surface and “that medium” through which things come into contact. The spatial standing-towards-each-other of two people, which shows itself in feeling, can, as Gwendolin Kirchhoff says in another conversation, be re-enacted in a family constellation.
How do you talk to people you disagree with?
In a conversation with Maik Hosang (2025), Gwendolin Kirchhoff names the idea “that everything has a fertile ground”: even if, say, a party doesn’t appeal to you, there are concerns underneath, and “the concern has to be addressed, otherwise nothing happens there.” That does not mean approving of everything, she says, but rather that “more crumple zone comes about.” The idea “that one shouldn’t even talk” “doesn’t necessarily have the effect that is hoped for.”
Do you have to agree with people who think differently?
In a conversation with Maik Hosang (2025), Gwendolin Kirchhoff says that opening the field for a conversation does not mean “that one has to convert to everything someone else says,” and: “that is no compulsion to consensus every time.” Of one such conversation of her own she says that she still assumed she was actually right in her view, but could listen well to his.

Explore these ideas further

If this line of thinking resonates and you'd like to pursue it in your own life — I'm happy to accompany you.

← All lexicon entries